10 Songs Ruined When Artists Revealed Their True Meanings
Ever belt out a song in your car, convinced you know exactly what it’s about, only to find out later you were wrong? You’re not alone. Musicians sometimes shatter our interpretations of their songs with interviews. The next time you listen to these 10 songs, expect a vibe change because you now understand their true meanings.
Every Breath You Take – The Police
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Wedding DJs have been playing this one at receptions for decades, and Sting thinks that’s hilarious. The Police’s 1983 hit topped charts worldwide and became a go-to slow dance number for couples in love. Too bad it’s actually about obsession and surveillance. Sting wrote the track while his marriage was crumbling. It was covering surveillance, jealousy, and ownership.
Total Eclipse of the Heart – Bonnie Tyler
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Jim Steinman loved writing dramatic power songs, and this 1983 hit delivered that. The single earned praise for being an emotionally exhausting love song and was synonymous with heartbreak and passionate romance. Unknown to many, Jim originally titled it Vampires in Love and later explained that the track was all about darkness, the power of darkness, and love’s place in the dark.
Semi-Charmed Life – Third Eye Blind
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Radio stations played an edited version of this 1997 hit all summer long, backmasking two words that would’ve given away the game. The melody and Stephen Jenkins’s rapid-fire delivery made it sound like sunshine and optimism. Thanks to an infectious guitar riff and other factors, listeners missed that the song chronicles a couple spiraling through a drug addiction. Stephen explained that the musical brightness was intentional.
In the Air Tonight – Phil Collins
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
According to rumor mills, Phil Collins once witnessed a drowning and wrote this song about it. Then he invited the guy who refused to help to a concert and called him out during the performance. Eminem even referenced the story. Sounds like a Hollywood-worthy revenge story. In reality, the 1981 track emerged during a spontaneous studio session, and Phil admits he doesn’t even know what the song means.
Hey Ya! – OutKast
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
André 3000 says in the song that people don’t want to hear what he’s saying and that they’d rather dance. He was right. Hey Ya! became the party anthem of 2003, winning awards and topping charts. People were too busy shaking it like a Polaroid picture per the lyrics. André 3000 explained that the track explores couples who stay together out of obligation and tradition, only to end up miserable for life.
You’re Beautiful – James Blunt
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
If you used this as your wedding song, James Blunt has some thoughts. The 2004 single earned three Grammy nominations and became a massive romantic hit, but James insists it’s actually creepy. To him, the song is about being high on drugs and obsessing over someone else’s girlfriend on the subway. The music video reinforces the darkness as he jumps off a cliff, suggesting the stalker’s story ends in tragedy.
Born in the U.S.A. – Bruce Springsteen
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Ronald Reagan’s 1984 campaign tried to use this as a rallying cry, which shows how poorly people interpreted the song. The rhythm and fist-pumping chorus fooled listeners into thinking Bruce was celebrating American pride. To him, it was a scathing protest song about how the country abandoned its Vietnam veterans. He’d witnessed homelessness, drug addiction, PTSD, and devastating physical injuries among some veterans.
Good Riddance (Time of Your Life) – Green Day
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Prom DJs have made this their closing song for years, and Billie Joe Armstrong finds that pretty funny. The acoustic song sounds sentimental and perfect for milestone moments, but Joe wrote it as a bitter breakup song when his girlfriend moved to Ecuador.
The One I Love – R.E.M.
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Peter Buck watched couples kiss during concerts and couldn’t believe what he was seeing. R.E.M.’s first Top 10 single became “their song” for romantic duos across America in 1987, and the band members were baffled. It was almost ironic because Michael Stipe nearly refused to record it, calling the lyrics “too brutal” and “really violent and awful.” After years of radio dedications, Michael gave up fighting it.
Closing Time – Semisonic
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
Dan Wilson predicted bartenders would adopt this as their unofficial anthem, and he was right. The 1998 hit became the universal signal that it’s time to finish your drinks and head home. It turns out Dan’s wife was pregnant, and he had babies in mind. Lines like “time for you to go out to the places you will be from” suddenly take on metaphorical meaning.
Fight for Your Right (To Party) – Beastie Boys
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
The ultimate party anthem of 1987 wasn’t supposed to celebrate partying at all. Mike D and the Beastie Boys wrote the track as a joke, mocking the same people who screamed the song at concerts. The satire went over everyone’s heads. According to Mike D, the only thing that upsets him is that they might have reinforced certain values in their audience, even though their own values were totally different.