How Two Brothers Destroyed One of the Biggest Bands of the 90s
In August 2009, one of the most successful British bands of its generation collapsed five minutes before walking onstage in Paris. The group had sold more than 75 million records worldwide. Stadiums were full, and a festival crowd of 30,000 was waiting. Then a backstage argument ended it all. The fight was about two brothers who had spent nearly two decades pushing each other to greatness and to the brink.
A Meteoric Rise Fueled by Friction
Image via Wikimedia Commons/Raph_PH
Oasis formed in Manchester in 1991, and its constant members were Liam Gallagher and Noel Gallagher. Liam handled lead vocals while Noel wrote the songs and played lead guitar. The division of labor worked beautifully on record and barely at all offstage.
Their 1994 debut album, Definitely Maybe, shot to No. 1 in the United Kingdom. A year later, (What’s the Story) Morning Glory? turned them into global stars with hits like Wonderwall, Don’t Look Back in Anger, and Champagne Supernova. By 1995, they were at the center of Britpop and selling out massive venues. But it turns out that success only amplified the friction between them.
In September 1994, during a show at the Whisky a Go Go in Los Angeles, Liam hit Noel with a tambourine. Noel quit on the spot and briefly retreated to Las Vegas before rejoining the band. The first American tour nearly ended before the band even broke through.
Violence, Insults, and A Charting Argument
Image via Freepik/drobotdean
In 1995, while recording “(What’s the Story) Morning Glory?” in Wales, tensions exploded again. Liam brought friends into the studio while Noel was working. Noel responded by hitting Liam with a cricket bat. The story became rock folklore, but it was not a joke inside the band. That same year, the brothers released a single titled Wibbling Rivalry, a recording of a heated 1994 interview, which charted in the United Kingdom. Few bands can claim that a sibling shouting match cracked the charts.
Public chaos followed. In August 1996, Liam pulled out of MTV Unplugged at the last minute, citing a sore throat. Noel performed alone while Liam watched and heckled from the balcony. Days later, Liam skipped the start of a United States tour. The tour was eventually canceled after another backstage altercation. The music was strong, but their relationship kept deteriorating.
The Moment It Turned Personal
The feud changed in May 2000 in Barcelona. During a night out, Liam questioned the paternity of Noel’s daughter, Anais, whose mother is Meg Mathews, and Noel punched him. He later said he never truly forgave the remark. He walked away from the European tour and stayed gone for the remainder of it. Studio disagreements and onstage antics were one thing, but family was another. The band carried on. Albums like “Standing on the Shoulder of Giants” and “Don’t Believe the Truth” kept them relevant.
Five Minutes In Paris
Image via Wikimedia Commons/Lara Janssen
The end arrived on August 28, 2009, at the Rock en Seine festival in Paris. Backstage, an argument erupted over multiple issues, including Liam’s clothing line, Pretty Green. Noel later said Liam grabbed one of his guitars and swung it “like an axe.” The guitar was smashed, and the band never took the stage. Noel released a statement that night saying he could not work with his brother “a day longer,” citing verbal and violent intimidation. Oasis was finished.
The fallout continued, and Liam sued Noel in 2011 after Noel suggested he had skipped a show because he was hungover. Liam said he had laryngitis, and the lawsuit was later dropped. Public insults carried on for years, including Liam repeatedly calling Noel a “potato” on social media.
The same rivalry that produced era-defining anthems also tore Oasis apart.